CERENO
← Resources

Admissions

AI in admissions essay review: a guide for admissions offices

Applicants use AI to write; offices are tempted to use AI to screen. That is the “two machines” problem—and the applicant’s own thinking gets lost between them.

What is happening

Reporting from GBH News describes colleges from public flagships to selective private institutions using AI to review essays, sort applicants by grades and test scores, flag possibly AI-generated essays and, in some cases, make full admissions recommendations—often with little oversight. Georgia Tech, for example, began using AI this year to review transcripts for nearly 68,000 applicants. AP News has reported similar uses of AI to analyse essays and applications, and the College Board’s 2025 survey of admissions professionals now tracks AI use in admissions.

Meanwhile, rules for applicants remain unclear: in Kaplan’s 2025 survey, 68% of colleges had no policy on using generative AI to write an admissions essay, and only 2% explicitly allowed it.

The risks for admissions offices

  • Rewarding polish over substance—especially when applicants can buy polish.
  • Penalising applicants who write in a second language, a pattern documented in AI essay scoring research.
  • Decisions you cannot explain to applicants, families or regulators.
  • Privacy and transparency concerns about how applicant data is processed.

Five principles for responsible use

  1. Use AI to organise evidence for readers, not to make admission decisions.
  2. Make every flag traceable to specific passages in the application.
  3. Audit outcomes by language and background every cycle.
  4. Keep decisions with people, with a clear route for review.
  5. Tell applicants how their work is reviewed, and publish your policy on their AI use.

CERENO Eval follows these principles: it does not guess authorship or judge character. It links what the essay shows to your criteria and leaves the decision with your readers.

Sources

  1. GBH News — With little oversight, colleges are using AI to handle admissions work (Nov 2026)
  2. AP News — AI may be scoring your college essay (Dec 2025)
  3. Kaplan — 2025 survey of college admissions officers on GenAI and essays
  4. College Board Research — Policy and practice in U.S. college admissions (Apr 2026)